Looks like a "healthy" sandwich right?We all know that we need to stay away from sugar, but are you eating "whole grain" bread? Whole wheat bread is high in sugar, higher than some candy bars and sugary sodas, and some scientists have proven that two slices of whole wheat bread will raise your blood sugar levels as high as if you were eating a candy bar.
Why does it take the mainstream media so long after a new study to report health benefits? BECAUSE they would lose all their advertising! I had to sign a waiver when I would be on TV that I won't bash whole grain or cereals.
It's really thing to wrap our mind around. According to the Life Extension article, eating two slices of whole wheat bread is worse than drinking a can of Coke or eating a candy bar. The original 1981 study at the University of Toronto found:
Glycemic Index:
White Bread = 69
Whole-grain Bread = 72
Wheat Cereal = 67
but Table Sugar (sucrose) = 52
That means the Glycemic Index of whole grain bread is higher than that of table sugar, which is also known as sucrose. For you "gluten free" readers out there...rice cakes are listed on the Glycemic Index at 77! This is why when people go "gluten free" and grab a lot of packaged "gluten free" items at the store, they gain weight rather than lose weight.
To read more, check out Oct 2011 issue of Life Extension magazine, "Wheat, the unhealthy whole grain," in the Oct. 2011 issue of Life Extension Magazine, page 82.
BUSY FAMILY TIP: Make a triple batch of this dough, bake and keep the sub bread in the freezer for an easy addition to your next picnic! All you have to do is cut open the bread (toast it if desired) and fill with your family's favorite filling. No need to stop at Subway or Quiz-no's. This will take you less time and save you tons of money.
"HEALTHIFIED" SUB
2 tsp baking powder
1 tsp Celtic sea salt
3 egg whites (8 egg whites if using coconut flour)
1 cup BOILING water (or MARINARA - for more Tomato Basil Bread!)
OPTION 2: Use 2 whole eggs (Almond flour version) or 4 whole eggs (coconut flour version). If you are having trouble with it rising using whole eggs you can try egg whites.
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. In a medium sized bowl, combine the flour, psyllium powder (no substitutes: flaxseed meal won't work), baking powder and salt. Mix until dry ingredients are well combined. Add in the eggs and mix until a thick dough. Add boiling water or marinara into the bowl. Mix until well combined and dough firms up.
Form into 4 to 5 mini subs (the dough will rise about 2 to 3 times so I start mine as a 1 inch disk, see picture below) or one large sub/loaf and place onto a greased baking sheet. Bake for 65 minutes (50 minutes for smaller shapes like buns). Remove from the oven and allow the bread to cool completely. Cut open with a serrated knife. Fill with desired fillings. Makes 5 servings.
NOTE! If you get a hollow bread, use less psyllium. We found that even within the same brand of psyllium (Jay Robb in our case) it can vary by how much it will rise. It there is a bubble the psyllium is too active and wants to rise too much. We had to cut back to 2 Tablespoons in our case and then it was great. The batter will be pretty sticky and almost runny but it will work (you can add an extra 1/4 to 1/2 cup almond flour if you want a less sticky dough and maybe slightly denser result).
NUTRITIONAL COMPARISON (per serving)
Traditional Sub Bread = 198 calories, 6g fat, 4g protein, 41 carbs, trace fiber (41 effective carbs)
Almond Flour Sub (egg whites) = 199 calories, 13.3g fat, 8.2g protein, 12.1g carb, 7g fiber (5.1g effective carbs)
Coconut Flour Sub (egg whites) = 136 calories, 1.7g fat, 8.2g protein, 21.2g carb, 17.5g fiber (3.7g effective carbs)
NOTE: SOME psyllium powder will turn your baked good a "rye bread" color. I have found that Jay Robb psyllium husks (ground into a powder) doesn't cause this to happen. Also, Bob's Red Mill Almond flour doesn't work. It is different than other almond flours.
![]() |
| Before and after. |
FILLING IDEAS:
CHICKEN CLUB: Smoked Chicken, bacon, tomatoes, lettuce, onions (see above photo)
TUNA MELT: Tuna, tomato, sharp cheddar: toast in a broiler until bread is crispy and cheese is melted (see bottom photo)
MEATBALL SUB: use my "healthiefied" meatballs and no sugar marinara
PIZZA SUB: fill with your favorite pizza toppings, no sugar marinara, mozzarella: toast in a broiler until bread is crispy and cheese is melted
PANINI: Cut bread into thin slices. Heat panini maker on high. Fill with desired sandwich fillings. Butter the outside of the sandwich and fry until bread is golden brown. Click HERE to find the panini maker I love, on sale now for $45! It was $90!
| Made into buns for Sloppy Joe's |
| Made into 'fingers' for Halloween Fun! |
Here is a video of the process of making these subs.
(Please Note: I use whole eggs in this video but we found that the yolks were causing it to not rise for some and become gummy. With just whites it is amazing!)

Thank you! I can't wait to try this recipe. My son begs me to stop at Subway every time we get in the car. I have been eating low carb/semi-paleo for a while now but it's been harder to get my kids to make the switch without a lot of complaining (they are actually young adults but have developmental disabilities and are very resistant to change.) I was so excited to find this site so now they can still have some of the things they enjoy while eating much healthier. I hope to buy your books soon.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the kind words and support! :)
DeleteLooks really good. Can you please tell me if the breads in the pics are made w the almond or coconut? Do you prefer one over the other?
DeleteYou must have read my mind! I've been craving a panini for a while. I'm making one tonight!
DeleteYES! I can't wait to try making these tomorrow. This may be a silly question...but with one recipe, do you just form one long sub, or 5 subs?
DeleteYou can make the subs as big or small as you like. When I made this one, I formed 5 subs before baking. :)
DeleteYou are a marvel and a life saver! May I please share your recipes on my Low Carb Club ZA page on Facebook, I will of course give you all the credit? louise@radicalmobility.com.
DeleteYes that would be fine. Please just link back to the original. :)
DeleteMaria, great looking bread! I just posted for you over on my FB page. :)
ReplyDeleteA question, you mention the dough rises up on baking. The two eggs in the recipe are all that I see to add levening power? Have you tried adding baking powder to this or also making a yeast bread with it?
If so, what happens?
Thanks!!! Beautiful sammy!
I haven't tried any levening powder. I don't think the yeast would work. It feeds on the sugars in regular bread to rise and those sugars aren't there in this one. :)
DeleteMaria, where do you get the psyllium husk powder? Isn't that what Metamucil is made of?
ReplyDeleteI get mine here. It basically 100% fiber. ;) http://astore.amazon.com/marisnutran05-20/detail/B000HZK1DE
DeleteHi Maria, we just discovered your blog (*LOVE*). We will be able to try this kind of recipe in a while after we complete our hCG and transition to Paleo.
ReplyDeleteYou mentioned "greasing" the pan for the dough. What do you use for the grease?
Thank you - UM&W
Thank You! I love this coconut oil spray. http://astore.amazon.com/marisnutran05-20/detail/B005TY1K0G
DeleteI just made this and mine came out very blue almost purple, is that normal? Have all your books. Reading "secrets to a healthy metabolism. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteIt does have a slight purple hue to it. The longer you let the dough sit, the more purple it gets. I left a batch over night and it was really purple (still tasted great!). So it's best to bake it right away. :)
DeleteOh, and thanks for your support!!
DeleteIn your GI comparison, how much sugar does that represent? I want to share this info with my mom (who is struggling to know what to cook other than bread, potatoes, rice and pasta) but the point would come across stronger if the amount were precise. Thank you. :)
ReplyDeleteThat doesn't represent an amount of sugar, it is a measure of how quickly the sugar enters our blood stream. The higher the number, the quicker and bigger the blood sugar spike (Bad!). To find the total amount of sugar that enters the blood from any food, just subtract the fiber from the total carbs and then divide by 4. That is the number of teaspoons of sugar in the blood. For example, 2 slices of whole wheat bread have 23.2g carbs, 3.8g fiber. So 23.2-3.8=19.4 divide by 4 equals 4.85 teaspoons of sugar in the bloodstream. A normal blood sugar at any moment is 1 teaspoon of sugar throughout the body. :)
DeleteI guess I need to do more research! I only had a vague idea about GI numbers, thanks for clearing that up for me!
DeleteOk, so I initially wasn't impressed with this dough recipe, because its really sticky and I am just a freak and don't like sticky things on my hands. lol. I was only able to make 2 decent size hoagies out of this. I used almond flour. With all the comments about it not rising, I wasn't expecting much, but it actually raised more than I thought, and looks like a whole grain bread! I cooked the two hoagies for 50mins, and just took them out, but it seemed to need a lil more time, so I just turned off the oven and have them in there. I plan to go one a hike tomorrow, and one of these hoagies is going on the trek with me. If I can cut them in half successfully (I am horrible at cutting bread), and it looks picture worthy, I will take a pic and post it on your FB page. Thanks as always, Maria!
ReplyDeleteStacy
Thanks! Yes, the key is to not overwork the dough. It will be sticky before baking. :)
DeleteSad face. They didn't turn out. The 'rise' was an illusion--a hollow air pocket. When I cut the hoagie open, it was still uncooked. Should I try coconut flour instead?
DeleteHow much did you work the flour? I'm trying to figure out what is causing some people problems. :)
DeleteWhat exactly do you mean "work?" lol. I used a hand mixer til it was combined and let it sit out for....5-10minutes before making it into two hoagies.
DeleteStacy
I bet the waiting is what affected it. I added the note to the recipe that it need to bake right away or they gel up and don't cook through. As soon as the ingredients are combined, I form the buns and put them straight in the oven. :)
DeleteI just made this, with high hopes for a good bread substitute. I had the same hollow result though, layer of thick dough on bottom and a high crispy crust with a huge pocket in the centre. I followed the recipe exactly and put in oven straight away, so don't know what the problem was. I've decided to give up on trying to make any low carb bread substitute.....they never work out for me.
DeleteTracy, was the water boiling? Also, what flour brand and type did you use? Bobs red mill doesn't work.
DeleteHi Maria.
DeleteYes, the water was straight from the boiling jug (I watched your video three times before I attempted this lol )
Not sure of the brand, don't think we get Bobs Red Mill here (in Australia). I haven't been able to get anything labelled almond 'flour', just almond meal and maybe that's the problem. I have blanched some raw almonds and am going to make my own 'flour'......then one more try. Looks like I've given up on giving up....?
I have made it with almond meal and it comes out fine. Maybe it was the psyllium. Was it a fine powder?
DeleteHello again. Thanks for the replies. I tried it again and this time it worked out! I did everything pretty much the same, the only thing I can think of is that I let it sit for a few minutes after mixing in the hot water, and maybe wasn't as fussy about getting it into a good shape, so I guess that's the key.
DeleteNice bread alternative, quite dense, but that's fine for me. Next time I will do rolls.
Thanks for the recipe and the help. Love your blog.
Awesome! Glad it worked out. :)
DeleteWe have the same problem. It is our first go. It looks good but seems to be hollow!
DeleteDid you use the egg white recipe update above? The egg white version rises better and gives more consistent results. The end product is a light fluffy bread like a wonder bread. If you like a more dense bread like a multigrain bread, you can try the whole egg version (2 eggs or 4 eggs with coconut flour). Thanks!
DeleteHi. Yes it was the egg white recipe. We only had husk though. But today we have psyllium powder. Any other suggestions before we much another lot up?
DeleteHaving psyllium husk powder is essential. If you have whole husks, you can grind them into a fine powder and that will work too, but it is easier to just get the powder. Good Luck! :)
DeleteGreat improvement with the husk powder. It eats fine but has turned purple. We did not hesitate, as soon as the mixture was finished we put it straight in the oven. So, the only thing different was the powder. We are improving though.
DeleteB and T
I finally decided to put some Psyllium Husk through the coffee machine and have a go, it came really fine when ground. This was quite great but my little buns were quite small and did not rise very much at all but this said, wow, it was so nice to have an actual hamburger with "bread". I only had the mince, the lettuce and some cheese and it actually tasted quite nice!!! I'm going to try a few more pf your recipes which call for "psyllium powder" now that I know the grinding trick works a bit!!
ReplyDeleteYay, Glad it worked out. :)
DeletePS: I wonder what makes the dough turn purple... very interesting!
ReplyDeleteHmm, I'm not sure about that one. :)
DeleteI think that you have this sussed now. Depends on the psyllium. I am going to search round in the UK to see if I can get the one that you use.
DeleteThanks again.
I love the flavor and texture of the sub rolls. Mine turned purple too. They taste great but look a bit funny!
ReplyDeleteI tripled the batch and baked in a regular bread pan and the middle has a spongy, damp texture to it. I baked it for longer than you suggested as it was too wet. It's also very dense. Any idea's what happened?
ReplyDeleteLondon
I think the key is to add the boiling water, mix just until combined and then place in the oven. The more you work this dough, the more it "Cooks" and gums up. :)
DeleteLove the bread! How do you store it? Does it need to be refrigerated? Thanks!!
ReplyDeleteYes, in the fridge. If I make a large batch I store them in the freezer. :)
DeleteCan you tell me about your process? About half the people are getting good results and other half aren't. How hot was the water, how much did you knead it, how long after needing did you bake it, etc. Thanks!
DeleteI kneaded mine a little long I think, because I had trouble forming it into the six small buns I wanted. It did work out though. I baked them the full 65 minutes and they came out great! They look and taste very much like whole wheat dinner rolls, which are also very puffed up and full of air. I tried a hot one with butter. Delicious!
DeleteThanks so much for this recipe, Maria! I love all kinds of bread, and since I went wheat free a year ago I've tried a lot of recipes with almond flour, coconut flour and flaxseed meal. I've been able to make some very good tasting muffins, but never anything that came close to a wheat roll or bun or loaf of wheat bread. Seems like it's the psyllium that makes the difference. This is the first time I've used it in a recipe.
Soon I'm going to make this recipe into 12 dinner rolls. I doubt that anyone will suspect they're not whole wheat!
I read your book, "Secrets to a Healthy Metabolism," and thought it was great. I recently purchased one of your cookbooks. I'm sure I'll buy more soon. :)
Thank Robert! Glad you liked them. Also, thanks for your support! :)
DeleteDo you know where we can get a big enough loaf pan to make a normal size loaf of bread? I think they make sub pans too?
ReplyDeleteI have lots of options here! :) http://astore.amazon.com/marisnutran05-20?_encoding=UTF8&node=20
DeletePossibly dumb question, but why heat the water at all? Is there a reason? Just found your blog and am in heaven. I'm fighting PCOS and trying to get pregnant (with the help of a doctor, which is SO expensive) and really need to get my hormones under control.
ReplyDeleteIf you don't add boiling water they won't rise at all. :)
DeleteMaria, do you use extra eggs if you use coconut flour? I know it absorbs a lot more than almond flour.
ReplyDeleteAfter retesting this recipe several times, I removed the coconut flour option. It just didn't bake through properly like the almond flour version.
DeleteHi:
DeleteI am unable to find your revised version of this recipe. The bread looks fantastic!
Did you just omit the reference to coconut flour, or were there any other changes?
Thanks for your help.
The above recipe is updated. There is an addition of baking powder and some tweaking of ingredient ratios and baking instructions. Good luck! :)
DeleteHow much coconut flour did you use? I only see measurements for almond flour. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteI recently removed the coconut flour option. It just didn't bake through as well as the almond flour. :)
DeleteAh, okay, thank you!
DeleteIs Psylliun seed husk powder that same as psyllium husk powder? I bought two different ones and that's what they were labeled. One was much more fine and a greyish color, the psyllium seed husk powder was more brown. I'm going to buy it in bulk next time.
ReplyDeleteThey should both work if they are both powder. Happy Baking! :)
DeleteHi Maria,
ReplyDeleteIs the butter supposed to be melted or room temp?
I am working on an update to this recipe. After about 7 pounds of almond flour I think I have it worked out! :) I will update in a couple days.
DeleteWant to try to make these…are you still getting people with the gummy uncooked problem using almond flour instead of the original coconut flour?
ReplyDeleteAlso I notice in the comments you talk about adding boiling water, but this is not mentioned in the recipe…just listed as " 1 cup water", or "add water"….Was the boiling water part for the coconut flour?
I am working on an update to this recipe. After about 7 pounds of almond flour I think I have it worked out! :) I will update in a couple days.
DeleteMade this last night and it came out looking like flatbread, nothing like the photo. Baked for the 65 minutes, and it was still gummy inside. I used it for a sandwich anyway, and it was pretty tasty. Looking forward to the recipe update!
ReplyDeleteIt appeared that the recipe had been updated so I tried it again last night. Fantastic! I couldn't believe how much the results looked like a whole wheat sub roll. Tasted great too. Thank you so much for this recipe. It will be a regular!
ReplyDeleteThanks! :)
DeleteWhere is the pdated recipe located? I made the coconut flour version tonight, before reading all the comments, lol. Gummy. But I will be eating it anyway, probably toasted. :o)
ReplyDeleteThe recipe is updated above. The Coconut flour version doesn't rise as well as the almond, but they should both work. :)
DeleteI'm giving this a go right now, back later with my verdict as I did have a few issues with the original recipe, but it was nice enough! Thanks Maria!! Sorry to hear about all those lbs of flour!!
ReplyDeleteOh yum! new recipe with almond flour, I used broth instead of water (as per the old recipe) and YUM! Love the modifications, makes the bread much nicer, less "funny" in the middle! Yay!!! i♥u and your recipes and all you do for us!!!
ReplyDeleteThanks France! Glad you likes it. ;)
DeleteI just tried the revised recipe and it turned out great! It's so nice to eat something that feels "bready". Hooray!!! :)
ReplyDeleteAwesome! :)
DeleteI made the updated recipe today using almond flour, and they turned out great! I sliced them in half to make garlic bread to go with zucchini noodle lasagna. My husband and I were so happy to have bread to sop up the sauce with again! Thank you, thank you, thank you!
ReplyDeleteThank you! :)
DeleteI just tried making this with the coconut flour. I didn't knead it though, I just mixed it. I divided it into 2 loaf pans & baked it for 1 hour. It turned out really rubbery.
ReplyDeleteI added a video of the process. Hope that helps. I have noticed that it cooks through better on a cookie sheet versus in a bread pan. Happy Baking! :)
DeleteI just made this - and it does come out crispy on the outside and a little moist on the inside, but it tastes good, like a whole grain bread. I did not wait until it cooled completely - I cut it open and spread some Delice De Bourgogne cheese (sp) on it and yum - finally I have something to spread my delicious cheese on. Thank you, Maria!! Also dipped into chicken soup with butter - quite yummy. - Camala :-)
ReplyDeleteThank you! :)
DeleteA couple of days ago I made six buns with this recipe and it came out great. Today I tried it with the tomato basil marinara and it bombed. The sauce was very hot, but not actually boiling, and that may have been the problem. Also, I added the cold eggs to the mix before adding the marinara, and that may have also been a reason for my small rolls coming out flat and gummy.
ReplyDeleteSo, while the oven was still hot, I started over and this time I used boiling water and I threw the eggs in after I had stirred the water in a little bit. When I add the boiling water, the mix immediately bubbles and fizzes. If that doesn't happen, then I know I'm in trouble.
The second batch (with the boiling water) had no problem rising, and it came out great.
Thanks for posting! The boiling water does seem to be key to them rising properly. Thanks!
DeleteCan these be stored on the counter? Or do they need to go in the fridge?
ReplyDeleteI store mine in the fridge or freezer. :)
DeleteThis is my all time favorite recipe. Husband who is not low carb prefers this recipe even over any other type of bread. Can't keep them around very long....go figure.
ReplyDeleteThank you Marilyn! :)
DeleteThis looks great! I must say, though, as I started reading the comments about the failed attempts, I was about to leave the page and not try it. I'm glad I read further to see you revised the recipe and everyone is having great results. Where do you get your almond flour?
ReplyDeleteThank you! I get mine here (honeyville):
Deletehttp://astore.amazon.com/marisnutran05-20?_encoding=UTF8&node=8
HELP! What did I do wrong? I followed the recipe precisely and was so excited when I saw the rolls rise in the oven. I took them out at 50 minutes and let them cool. Big surprise when I cut into a cooled one, it was all air inside, no bread! I used Yerba Prima brand of Psyllium husk powder, would that make a difference? I also thought, ok just put some butter on the inside to try a taste, and honestly it was gross.
ReplyDeleteI so thought that this would work and I would be able to take a roll with me when I go out for lunch or dinner, and at least have some kind of bread with my meal. What do you think is the problem with what I did?
Thanks - Sandi ☺
Have you watched the video I added above? I haven't tried that psyllium, but it looks like it should work. You could try another brand. Happy baking! :)
DeleteI had the same problem. I made the coconut flour version, used a cookie sheet, powdered psyllium husk, and followed all instructions. They looked great but when I opened them, they were wet and they caved in. The worst part was the smell. I think the smell was the psyllium husk powder. It was disappointing bc they looked so good. Love all the other recipes I've tried from your site. Has anyone had the smell problem with this bread??
DeleteI would try a different psyllium. One of the things I love about this bread is that is smells just like my moms fresh made bread when I was a kid. :)
DeleteI'm going to try the revised coconut flour recipe (almond allergy).
ReplyDeleteI will try using room temp eggs (vs. cold), since by reading the comments, it seems that hot boiling water is imperative. Maria, are your eggs room temp?
I don't bring my eggs to room temp but you could do that if you like. The water has to be boiling. I pour mine straight out of my whistling tea pot. :)
Deletejust made this for first time. i used coconut flour...it turned out perfectly! i loved them. been on a quest for non-bread bread. this has ended the quest for me! I cant wait to double the batch and make in a loaf pan.
ReplyDeletei made it as you presented it with the recipe. i have a cuisinart water filter machine that makes hot water...so water was quite hot. as it was very sticky i added a little bit of oil on the outside of the dough to more easily form them without sticking to my fingers and this helped alot. i did not overwork them and as i stated they turned out perfectly!
Thank you for another great recipe!
Thank you! Glad you liked them. I love the smell of fresh cooked bread that they have. :)
DeleteMaria I followed your video to a T and it came out perfect. Thank you so much. I bought your kindle book today also. I used almond flour
ReplyDeleteKathleen Miller
Yay! Thanks for your support! :)
DeleteWhat an amazing recipe! I've been dreaming of a recipe that looked and tasted like real bread, and this is it! I used coconut flour and made sure to shape my buns the way I wanted them to look when they were done. I noticed that people were saying they didn't raise much. Mine were absolutely perfect! You are my new baking hero Maria!
ReplyDeleteThank you! Glad you liked it. I used over 10 pounds of almond flour getting this one right! :)
DeleteTried this recipe this evening and they turned out great! We stuffed them with carnitas and had some coleslaw on the side.
ReplyDeleteFantastic! My honey said "I love your buns" LOL!!
BTW - they are very filling.
Thanks for sharing.
Dee
Funny! Love it! :)
DeleteI forgot to mention that I baked my five mini subs for 50 mins, then turned the oven off & left the bread in the oven for another 15 or 20 mins. The outside was crispy and the inside was perfectly done. The two that were left from last night's dinner, I stored in the refrigerator in a ziploc bag. Today they were still just right to eat with some chicken salad.
DeleteThanks again, Maria.
I made these as five small breads using the coconut flour and shared them with two other people eating gluten-free and low-carb. They are wonderful! There is another batch just out of the oven that I added 1/2 tsp. each of garlic powder and oregano. This recipe is over-the-top better than store bought gluten-free bread! Thank you for sharing this!
ReplyDeleteThanks Gretchen! This is a regular at our house for buns, subs, bread, pizza dough, etc. :)
DeletePS - I forgot to mention that I also loved your book 'Secrets to a Healthy Metabolism' and wrote a review on my blog as well as gifting my sister and sister-in-law each with a copy. One of the ladies that I shared the bread with also purchased a copy. Great information for the metabolically challenged :-)
Deletehttp://www.gfedge.com/2012/10/secrets-to-a-healthy-metabolism-by-maria-emmerich/
Thanks! :)
DeleteI could not get the Jay Robb psyllium husks and so I got the Yerba psyillium powder. The bread rose beautifully, but it was wet inside and spidery (my daughter's description)and a bit gummy. I see there is an updated recipe, but all I see at the top is one with coconut flour as an option and you said it was not an option on the new recipe. Sooo where does one find the updated recipe? Thanks!
ReplyDeleteThe above recipe is updated. What brand almond flour did you use?
DeleteI just made this. Mine sank in the middle when i removed it from the oven............ and I used almond meal as i was out of the flour...........It is yummy. Just worried that it has 10 carbs per 1/5 of a serving. I want to double it next time to make a loaf...........
ReplyDeleteThe 10g is almost all fiber so I don't count that. :)
DeleteOk yes I know see the 3.3 net carbs............Thank you.
DeleteI made this before and didn't shape the sub so good-did you double your batch for that or what's the secret to make a usable sub? lol How long was it and that? Also for the buns I bought a mini muffin top pan-could I make buns with this in there? Think I may try it again if I can get it right
ReplyDeleteI just made one big sub out of a whole batch for the photo. This bread is very filling and you would be very callenged to eat the whole thing! :) The pan would work. Thanks! :)
DeleteI am going to buy the physillum husk but need to know the amount I need to buy. There are different sizes in your amazon store link.
ReplyDeleteHolly
Depends on how often you are going to make this bread. I typically buy a 24 oz bag. Thanks! :)
DeleteI just found your blog yesterday looking for a grain free bread recipe - I made these last night with coconut flour -OMG best grain free bread I've had to date! They did turn out kind of purple-ish in color but the taste & texture were fantastic. Thank you for a great recipe!!
ReplyDeleteAwe, you made my day! Thanks! The purple comes from the NOW brand psyllium husks. I have used a couple others (Jay Robb and another organic brand from the local health foods store) that didn't turn it purple. :)
DeleteI love it! I made these today and they turned out so wonderful! i am so grateful! i wanted some more light bread and i love it!
ReplyDeleteEven our friend who had lunch with us didn't want the white bread anymore! He loved it too! I am totally SOLD on these ones! love it!
thanks for the recipe, it turned out great, no airholes, no purple colour, looked like a wonderful "wholegrain" bread roll! Wonderful.
I made some pictures in case you'd like them
Thanks! Glad you liked it. I would love if you posted the photos on my facebook page here :)
Deletehttp://www.facebook.com/pages/Maria-Mind-Body-Health/337393421445
I made rolls for sloppy joes!! They were amazing!! I used almond flour and it was easy peasy to make. The whole family liked them too. So nice to know the exact ingredients in our food. I will post the pics on your facebook. :)
ReplyDeleteAwesome! Thank you! :)
DeleteI made my first batch with almond flour and they were ok (had a bit of a funny taste to them and were kinda "webby" inside. BUT...I have made my last 3 batches with coconut flour and am in LOVE with these! To me, the coconut flour produced a lighter, fluffier and more bread-like consistency with no coconut taste. Thanks so much Maria!!
ReplyDeleteThank you! :)
DeleteMy first loaf is in the oven now. I just checked it and looks beautiful! I didn't use an electric mixer, just a wire whisk and a wooden spoon. I used Coconut Secrets Coconut flour and Now brand psyllium powder. Can't wait to see how it turns out!
ReplyDeleteMy loaf looked beautiful, but when I cut it, it was a little under-done, so, I sliced it open and baked it a little longer. It tasted good, but was pretty dense. I decided to try a wrap instead. I used your quesadilla wrap recipe and LOVE it! Thanks so much for all your great recipes!
DeleteThanks MaryLynn. I will be posting a couple extra tips for this recipe to help get it right. Hopefully they will be posted later today. :)
DeleteI made buns tonight with almond flour, they turned out fantastic! They top half of the bun was "airier" than the bottom but they tasted great with a slice of fontina cheese!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for developing and posting the recipe! I can't wait to try it with coconut flour.
FYI, I substituted one of the eggs for egg white substitute and added a few teaspoons of Nutritional Yeast and 1 tsp of onion powder.
I have a picture on my FB page, sorry about the lighting, it doesn't do the colour of the buns justice, they are a nice whole wheat colour.
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151141446330894&l=ac04e6ee6d
Thank you for posting the photo! :) Can you tag me in your photo? Thanks!
DeleteFB Wouldn't allow me to tag for some reason even though I have the picture set as visible to the public. I uploaded it your FB page with a link back to this page. :)
DeleteThanks for trying. :)
DeleteMaria, I am in a conundrum. The text recipe for these call for two egg whites, but your video shows you adding in two whole eggs. I take it that I should add the whole eggs?
ReplyDeleteThanks for clarifying!
Hi, I just updated the recipe to include only whites. I found that the inconsistency that some people were seeing was a reaction between the fat in the yolks and the psyllium. It works great every time with just whites! :)
DeleteOMGoodness! These were SO GOOD! Thank you!
DeleteThank you!
DeleteIs it egg whites or whole eggs. I'm about to make this. Gonna do the whites and see how it turns out. The video has whole eggs. Just want to be sure. Wish me luck.
ReplyDeleteWe found that is rises better and more consistently using only egg whites, especially with the almond flour version. :)
DeleteTurned out perfect. Thanks. :)
DeleteAwesome! :)
DeleteFunny. I had this on my "to try" list for awhile and just finally had the required ingredient and did it today, but before your update :) I used psyllium seed husk powder as that's what I found. And I made four buns out of it. (I did watch the video first, so good to know what it should look like ahead of time). And they were perfect perfect perfect. Egg yolk and all. I made the crab sandwich from another posting. Just happened to find a big can at Costco this afternoon by chance. And happened to make bacon this morning by chance. It was meant to be. I froze two to test that out and am very excited. My husband is only so so on the egg buns / revolution rolls --- he might really eat a burger or a sloppy on these !!!!!!!!!!!!!! Awesome.
ReplyDeleteAwesome! Thank you! :)
DeleteSo are you supposed to use egg whites or the whole egg? It says egg whites on the recipe but in your video it looked like you used whole eggs..........I made them with just whites and they were very wet and gummy/undercooked in the center, even after an hour and a half.....
ReplyDeleteIt is egg whites. We just determined that the yolks were keeping it from rising for some people and making it gummy. With just whites it is awesome! :)
DeleteThanks for all the great information on breads but I was wondering why you put the husk in the receipe. Doesn't it give a laxative effect.
DeleteI write in my book how to slowing increase your fiber intake. Most Americans get way less fiber than they really need. ;)
DeleteMine turned out a bit weird, but I guess it was because I used 2 whole eggs. The taste was really good, but they rised in the oven and the tops of them were hollow when I sliced them!
ReplyDeleteTry it with only egg whites. Rises much better. :)
DeleteHow did you form the calzones?
ReplyDeleteJust press into a flat circle, add ingredients to 1/2 of it and fold the other half over. Then press the edges together to seal. :)
DeleteI made the subs before, they turned out great, was feeling brave so I doubled the recipe for a real loaf of bread.. dough was fantastic, not sticky, almost filled the pan to the top before baking. I was excited. My beautiful bread fell before taking it out of the oven. I sliced a piece and have gummy center :( What did I do wrong? I followed the recipe, doubled it, added egg whites-we're not supposed to whip these stiff right?, incorporated the eggs a little bit in the dough then added my boiling water and it foamed, Mixed with mixer. Should I should be using my hands. I had a dough that wasn't sticky and was all together. I used Honeyville almond flour. Baked at 350 for 60 min. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteFor some reason when this is made in a bread pan, the bottom doesn't cook properly. I have made a loaf just on a cookie sheet (using the coconut flour option) that raised up about 3 times its size and although it is only a mini loaf, it still worked well for bread. :)
DeleteI had a Panini today and I am soooo happy! I haven't had a Panini in well over a year and they used to be my favorite way to eat a sandwich. It's been so long, I wasn't sure my Panini maker was even going to work!
ReplyDeleteThank you for providing this recipe, Maria, and the idea to make a yummy, hot, grilled sandwich. I made 4 "rolls" last night and was pleased at how much they rose and how soft they still were this morning. The video really helped me with the prep. Like others, I've tried many wheat free bread options and this is the best one yet!
Keep ‘em coming!
Oh, I also purchased your book, Secrets to a Healthy Metabolism. I devoured it! Great information!
Awesome! I'm glad you liked it. Thanks for posting! :)
DeleteMaria, I haven't read all the comments, so perhaps this has been asked already. If so, I apologize. I made this bread, as a sub, with the tomato basil sauce. It had a wonderful flavor but was very heavy. Did I do something wrong or did the sauce make it heavier than it would be with water? It tasted more "authentically bread-like" that most any other low-carb, gluten-free bread I've made, so I really want it to work, but sure would like it to be a little lighter. I am not a white-bread person. I've only eaten whole-grain, hearty bread for years but now am LC, GF so that's not the issue. It was just so dense and heavy. Any suggestions?
ReplyDeleteHi, you have to make sure the liquid is boiling hot. Also, did you use psyllium husk powder? It has to be a fine powder to work (I grind mine in a blender). Thanks! :)
DeleteHi, Maria
ReplyDeleteI made this recipe and it ROCKS! http://j3nn.net/blog/2012/11/10/low-carb-grain-free-gluten-free-bread-rolls/
Thank you :)
Thanks! Glad you liked them. :)
DeleteI made the coconut flour version of this (to avoid excess omega 6 of almond flour) and it turned out pretty well. The outside gets really crunchy and golden and the inside formed nice big holes. I made mine about 50% smaller than recommended and still ha to almost double the cooking time- maybe it was because of the coconut flour. The inside was a bitty gummy still by the end but I ended up just cutting it into slices and then browning up the middle. Was really nice with butter. I’m going to try making a really flat one to minimise the amount of “middle” next time. Also, I want to try it as a meat pie crust. I added a tsp of poppy seeds and a teaspoon of sesame seeds to the mix for extra pizazz :p
ReplyDeleteAh, but admittedly I used psyllium husks but not the powder. Can I just put the husks in the blender to turn them into a powder?
ReplyDeleteAs it states above, you have to use psyllium powder or this recipe won't work. I just put mine in my Blendtec blender for a while until a fine powder. You could also use a coffee grinder. ;)
DeleteI ground down the psyllium husk with a mortar and pestle (didn't work in the blender- just blew around). It was a good workout :)
DeleteReally cool, definitely nicer with the powder. I still had to cook mine longer than recommended. Not sure why. The only thing I did differently now was use baking soda plus vinegar instead of baking powder because all the baking powders i've come across are full of non-paleo junk and preservatives. I'm excited to try and work out what I should use them for! It's been so long since I have had bread that I have no idea what to put on them that will be nostalgic. I used to do chicken avocado and cheese but I don't eat dairy anymore. And as an Aussie doing paleo, grain-based vegemite spread is out too. I'm thinking cinnamon and coconut cream wil remind me of when I used to put ricotta and cinnamon on bread. Off to try it now!
I ended up having firm coconut cream (reminiscent of ricotta) salt and olive oil on the bread. Was excellent. It didnt even cross my mind that it wasn't real bread.
DeleteAwesome! Glad it worked out! :)
DeleteHi, Maria! Do you really mean half a cup of coconut instead one and a half of almond meal? I can hardly wait to make this
ReplyDeleteYes, if doing the coconut flour option, it is 1/2 cup coconut flour and 8 egg whites (or equivalent egg white liquid).
DeleteThank you very much!
DeleteOh woow these were fantastic. I did not have almond flour, only moderately pulsed almonds, and not even 1 1/4 cup, only 1 cup. added 1/4 cup of what I had in my pantry, soy flour, which is a fairly reasonable low carb alternative I think. I sprinkled the subs with some cinnamon. Also, half way through the baking process I flipped them over to prevent the "dough on the bottom" phenomena. Not sure it had any impact, my the bread turned out delicious with evenly distributed "filling".
ReplyDeleteI've had celiac disease for 23 years and never have I been able to bake such a great gluten free bread on my own, and believe me, I have tried! The fact that it's low carb is almost too good to be true!! Thank you for a great recipe!! Will come back to this recipe many many times more!
Thanks Isabella! :)
DeleteCan you bake this in a bread machine?
ReplyDeleteI don't have a bread machine so I haven't tried it. If you do, let me know if it works. :)
DeleteOK! I'm always up for a challenge. I'll experiment and let you know!
DeleteFYI, does NOT work in a bread machine! Worth trying! Did not cook through so I had to throw the whole thing out. Oh, well. That's the price of experimentation! I did successfully make some rolls with both the almond and coconut flour recipes on a cookie sheet in the oven. The coconut recipe came out better actually. With the almond flour, I had to use 1 1/2 cups instead of 1 1/4 cups. Not sure why, maybe because I live at flat sea level(or maybe a little below-wetlands, flood plain). Thanks so much for your recipe!
DeleteThanks for trying and reporting back so others know. Thank you! :)
DeleteHi Maria:
ReplyDeleteI tried your original recipe a week or so back using almond flour & whole eggs. The mini subs were very good (as I reported back to you), but they didn't rise much.
Yesterday, I tried the "new & improved" version using coconut flour & egg whites. Wow! Those buns really did rise while they baked. I formed six, and they rose to the size of regular hamburger buns! Tasted great too.
Thanks again for a super recipe.
Awesome Deidre! Glad you liked it. It is a bread staple at our house! :)
DeleteI'm trying to find out why it's not working when I make it. My dough stays sticky and soft even after beating it for a few minutes. When you measure your almond flour, do you pack it or just stick the measuring cup in the container and shake it a little to get it even at the top? I just scoop in the bag and do a light shake to get off the excess and wondering if I'm actually putting in less almond flour than I should be. It definitely doesn't look nice and dry look yours does in the video.
ReplyDeleteThe only 2 things that seem to make this not work are the brand of almond flour (Bob's Red Mill doesn't work, it is a different product than other almond flours) and not have a fine powder on the psyllium husk (the finer the better). Good luck! :)
DeleteJust a note: When I made this with almond flour, I used almonds I had ground myself; the recipe worked fine.
DeleteThanks Deidre! :)
DeleteI have a loaf in the oven now! I can't wait to make a toasted "pizza" sub with it! I'll report back later!
ReplyDeleteHoly moly these rolls are wonderful! I made them for the third time yesterday, this time with the coconut flour option and NOW brand psyllium husk powder (yay! no more purple!) and just egg whites and they are simply divine (I had the rising/falling, hole in the middle, soggyness problem that others experienced before). I went to a big craft festival with my family yesterday and popped a roll in my purse so that I could get a pit beef sandwich from a vender (not grass fed, but I make exceptions once in a while)--brought along my homemade mayo, too, and mixed it with the horseradish they had and I was in heaven. ;) Trying to plan ahead for Thanksgiving, so I just cubed up the remaining rolls and toasted/dried them out in the oven--I'm going to mix them with cubes of the protein bread done up the same way for our stuffing. My folks aren't following my WOE, so it's a huge deal to me that they are letting me make the stuffing! I bet it's going to be awesome.
ReplyDeleteThank yo so much Cristina! It took a lot of trial and error to get them right but they are pretty great now! :)
DeleteSorry, but there doesn't seem to be a way to post a comment to the post itself (only to a comment to the post).
DeleteMaria- have you ever tried making these into a sourdough? They really look like they should have that nice tart sour taste of a sourdough. I don't know if adding some vinegar or lemon juice would mess up the chemistry of it (I'm not much of a baker), but you are.
I'm revving up my courage to try these. Thanks.
Agreed! Oh and I just tasted one of the dried out cubes. Helloooooo mock pumpernickel croutons! So good!
DeleteRoxie, I haven't but that sounds like a good idea! I would replace the equal amount of water for whatever you add. Good luck and let me know how it turns out! :)
DeleteI tried this today. I left it in for 75 minutes. It was still pretty gooey in the middle ( I cooked as a whole loaf ). Flavor was great. I did use Red Mill. It seems to be the only kind I can get. Why does it not work? I'll try it again using an electric mixer as this was the only think I did differently from the video.
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure why Bob's doesn't work but a couple people have posted that it didn't work with Bob's but does with others like Honeyville. :)
DeleteMaria, I made those following your video instructions closely, and the taste turned out great, they rose well, but for some reason the inside was not cooked well and didn’t raise that much, they reminded of a bubble with perfect crust and half baked base (I cooled them before cutting). I had to cut them open and out in the oven to bake the insides like that. Do you have any idea what could possibly go wrong? May be the temperature too high? I love this bread and hope to make it right next time. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteHmm, maybe try starting them out flatter. They raise a lot with just whites so if you start them at about 1/2 thick disks, they will raise to a nice bun size. That may help with the cooking through. :)
DeleteAlso, the almond flour version does seem to be more consistent. :)
DeleteI don't normally comment on recipes I find, but I just have to tell you how amazing this recipe is! I LOVE bread and not being able to eat it has been killing me. Most bread substitutes are really dry, dense, and heavy but this is so fluffy and soft. It's just like french bread and is so delicious, so healthy, and super easy to make. I just want to thank you a million times over for sharing such an amazing thing! Thank you!!!
ReplyDeleteThank you! I am glad you liked them! :)
DeleteStill loving this recipe. I experimented and made pizza bread the other day! I used pizza sauce instead of the water, added 2 tbsp of your pizza hut spice mix, chopped pepperoni, sun dried tomatoes and grated mozzerella on top. Delicious!
ReplyDeleteThat sounds amazing! Yum! :)
DeleteWhoo hoo! Finally, after a good many of those batched, I've got it! I have something that looks and tastes like bread!!! I'm so excited. I'll get some pics for your wall Maria! The only thing I did differently this time is raise the temperature of my oven. All ovens are different and I remember you said you had a convection oven, which right off the bat is 20°C more for my oven! I put them in on 400°F, and after 10 minutes turned it down to about 380°F (on my oven, all I know is that it was hotter than the usual 350°F I used to use) and they rose, and unlike last time, they weren't hollow! They actually look like bread and aren't gritty like they used to be, nor rubbery, nor spidery!!! *yay* Yum!!! I'm so excited that I persevered!
ReplyDeleteThanks France! We do love these, especially the almond flour version. Made amazing buns! I added the note above about the convection oven. Thanks! :)
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete